100's of guests comments
Guest book
There are 2 guest books at Buttercup Cottage, both crammed with literally 100's of guest comments over the years. We have loved reading through both of them with a fire lit. We can’t tell you how much we love hearing about our guests' stay and we are so proud that everyone loves the cottage as much as we do. There are also some great tips from guests for visiting Castleton, some walks around Mam Tor and Edale Valley.
Update June 2026
It's been a while since we have updated this page with our guest notes, in fact the last time we did it was up to 31st July 2024. The following feedback is from Jan 2026 - June 2026 and are lifted directly into text. It makes us to happy to read this feedback, thank you :-)
We absolutely loved the cottage. It had everything we needed. Excellent location. We loved evenings in the living room with the fire on. We would love to come back & visit. Great stay.
Another 5★ review from us! A great stay, cottage is beautiful, location is perfect. Comes from host excellent.
We will be back! :-)
-----
Yet another lovely stay in Buttercup Cottage, and we have every intention of coming back.
Ideally situated, everything anyone could want in the cottage, lovely welcome pack. Perfect.
The B******'s.
-----
Wow what a find. Fab welcome pack, beautiful cottage. Packed with all the amenities needed. We had a fantastic walk up Mam Tor and enjoyed meals out at the Castle and the Old Cheshire Cheese Inn. 5★ reviews from us, couldn't have asked for a better stay in such beautiful surroundings. Thank you Mark and Ed for sharing your wonderful home.
-----
It's like a home from home, peaceful/fabulous idyllic location, lovely welcome pack, great visitors' folder. Everything is perfect for hiking – our kind of holiday! Will be back soon to explore & discover more. Fabulous dog hikers. xxxx
-----
We had such a wonderful stay, the best cottage we have ever stayed in - loved every minute - Highlights - Dragons Back - 3 Peaks, lovely food at Robinsons and Bulls Head - Thank you very much!
-----
This was our first time coming up to the Peak District and Buttercup Cottage was the perfect place to stay, getting to see Luds church, Roaches, Mam Tor - and from the garden, Cave Dale (fab) dragons back and more! But getting to come back to Castleton and get cosy with the fire on and a glass of wine made it!
Can't wait to come back already, the BEST place! ♡
-----
Wow. Weather was beautiful, where better to have morning coffee outside. Walked Mam Tor & Great Ridge, Dinner at George Inn, Peveril Castle & Cave Dale walk next up to Winnats Pass (walking poles recommended). Great toastie at Tilly's, coffee at Castleton Coffee Company.
-----
Went to Eyam, Plague village - lovely tea room! Walk at Padley Gorge, very busy - Half Term (I work in Education so have no choice!). Haddon Hall & Chatsworth a must if you love history & Art then 8 1/2 mile walk at Derwent Water. Peak District Fairholmes. Lovely cottage - everything you need. As turn can right way.
-----
Hard to explain how relaxing + comfy this cottage is. If you are cooking here there is nothing missing in the kitchen. Beds comfy, shower great, a lovely village (even in the rain) - what more do you want. Our 2nd stay here + hopefully not our last.
We had a wonderful stay. The location is beautiful and the property is very well equipped with everything needed for a comfortable visit. It's ideally located for Mam Tor. The outdoor space is peaceful and relaxing. We would happily return and highly recommend it to others.
😊 ♡ x x
We had a wonderful stay. What a fantastic location, we made the most of the excellent tours / walks you can do by foot. Our thighs may never forgive us for Mam Tor, but wow, what a view. Also, a long walk, what an excellent cottage to come back to. So thoughtfully appointed. We loved it and hope to be back!
-----
Thank you so very much to all who have put time + effort + love into making this such a special place. An oasis. Thank you x
-----
Thank you so much for creating such a magical place! We have all had such a relaxing week at Buttercup Cottage! This cottage instantly makes you feel at home! The location is superb; so many wonderful walks from the doorstep, as well as being able to look around Castleton! Very sad to leave!
-----
The cottage has been just perfect! We really appreciated the thought to include an emergency basket and the views from the garden have been spectacular! Would come again, the perfect place to come back to after a long day hiking and walking. Thank You!!
-----
We were last here 2021 – still gorgeous! Had a lovely time – weathered sunny everyday. Hopefully will return!
-----
What a perfect cottage! We've stayed in Castleton before but this was by far the best! The views from the garden are so relaxing. Cottage was so well equipped – with everything you could need – thanks for the welcome pack! Visited Windyman / Treak Cliff Cavern along with all 7 pubs in town – much enjoyed! Particular highlights were pizza at the George + Roast at the Bulls Head. We will be back!
-----
We have absolutely loved every minute in this gorgeous cottage + village, its been so relaxing + we have slept so well! It did state there was a hamper with drink + snacks, we didn't have this, however, there was everything else dishwasher tablets, laundry powder, bathroom nessesities, salt / pepper + condiments so really not complaining. Everything has been perfect. We visited all the pubs in the village which served lovely food, especially the black bull the walks are so scenic + the caverns are worth a visit, we will be definitely returning, would like to visit at Christmas time, magical x x
-----
We've had a wonderful few days in Castleton! The cottage was the perfect escape from busy city life. Thankyou so much for your hospitality and lovely touches (like the hamper!). Would love to come back x
-----
We've loved our short stay – the cottage is perfect in everyday! The welcome hamper was a lovely touch – thank you. Great location, lovely walks, and happy dogs!
-----
Wonderful location within minutes of all the amenities. Amazingly quiet and restful. Great walks from the doorstep. Won't hesitate to return.
5*'s
-----
What a beautiful cottage and wonderful location. So well equipped and cosy we slept so well and enjoyed sitting around the fire with a glass of wine! We'll definitely be back soon.
Thank you for the warm welcome!
R
-----
Our 3rd stay at Buttercup. We love this cosy cottage and everything the area has to offer. Fantastic walks up Mam Tor, despite the weather! Lovely food at the Castle & Dolly's Tea Rooms. Hope to return soon x
Our 1st stay at Buttercup and we'll definitely be back. The cottage is so beautiful and cosy. We had a lovely breakfast at Dolly's Tea Room and sampled the best pubs in the village. Thank you so much x
-----
Fabulous little cottage + perfect base to explore the wonderful hills + landscape of the northern peaks. Had some brilliant sunshine + a bit of snow, so great for walking. Buttercup cottage is well located, warm + cosy + well equipped. Definitely on our list of return cottages! Thanks!
-----
Great cottage, great location, great holiday
Thank you
J*****, M**** and Freddie (the dog)
-----
Beautiful cottage with everything we needed. Perfect location for walks. It was our 1st visit to the Peak District and we had a wonderful time.
Thank you lots. S****, S******, L*****, R*****, J**** & Charlie 🐶 ❤️
-----
Another great stay. Great location. Everything we needed. Apart from the weather!! But will be back. Thanks
-----
These guest comments have been lifted directly and not edited in any way are the last 5 pages dating to 31st July 2024. We hope you will write in our book on your next stay.
-------
We had a lovely time staying in this cottage and we enjoyed the fire in the evenings.
-------
We have been very comfortable here, enjoying walks followed by local pub. The cottage is very well equipped and cosy. Thank you.
-------
A lovely cottage, beds are very comfortable! All the Pubs in town are great, we particularly liked the Nags Head & Peak Hotel. We can recommend the Silver & Store Shop for Blue John. Banford Edge & Mam Tor are a must, spectacular views on a clear day. Thank you very much x
-------
A lovely warm and cost cottage. Stay in Castleton but this is our first at Buttercup Cottage. Very well equipped. Lovely Kitchen and bathroom. Walked several miles every day. Bulls Head meals are great.
-------
2nd wonderful stay here. HOPE TO BE BACK!
-------
Great cottage, lovingly thoughtfully restored. Very comfortable, ideal situation. Many lovely walks close by. I thoroughly recommend the Castleton Coffee Co. Jon How Lane for good coffee and delicious pastries & savoury snacks. Thanks for the welcome pack.
-------
Second time staying here and just as wonderful as the first! Love all the little changes you have made. Buttercup Cottage feels like a home away from home, thank you and can't wait for next time! Lily
-------
What lovely lovely cottage, in the most sublime of settings . First time visit to the Peak District & it won't be our last. THANK YOU!
-------
Fantastic cottage in a lovely location with plenty of attractions nearby. to explore with the dog. Had a great time X
-------
Another lovely time at Buttercup Cottage. The snow was a bonus, pity it didn’t last so that we had to to stay longer - snowed in :-). Hopefully see you again!
-------
Lovely cottage in a beautiful spot, perfectly placed for exploring the Peak District! After some wonderful walks (including Mam Tor & Kinder Scout) we enjoyed coming back here to cosy up in front of the fire. We had everything we needed while here - would like to come again!
-------
Wonderful to be back in castleton, been visiting for over 30yrs. Stayed in the village many times. Buttercup cottage is very special and a delight to stay in - We will be back! Thank you
-------
Fabulous cottage, perfect location & very cosy. We loved reading about the history of the cottage. We would love to come back soo. Thank you for a lovely break :-)
-------
Beautiful, warm & friendly cottage. Buttercup cottage had everything we needed, felt at home. as soon as we walked in, lovely warm, & cosy. Perfect location. Thanks again 🙂
-------
Had a fantastic time, beautiful homely Cottage. Definitely be back for some more exploring. Fell in love with the Peak District on our first ever stay.
-------
First time visiting the Peak District. Lovely cosy cottage in a beautiful village. Some great walks from the door- a highlight was walking over to Edale the onto Kinder scout, the sun even came out for us that day. Definitely recommend Sunday lunch at 'The George' but advise you to book ASAP.
-------
We’ve had a lovely holiday, + would like to come back in the future. The best part is coming back each day to your lovely cottage ever so comfortable & well equipped. Blue has enjoyed it too.
-------
By far the best accommodation & location we have stayed in the Peak District. Fantastic walks on the doorstep & great local businesses. Will 100% come back, Thank you.
-------
Second time staying in this lovely village. 1st time in your lovely cottage. Two five mile walks from the front door. Stunning scenery and fantastic weather. Lots of lovely beal pubs with log fires and great beer. Will be back as soon as we can!